
The first few weeks of high school can be hard enough: Students try to find their footing in a wildly new environment, and tests loom around the corner. But for freshmen coming from the GDS middle school, it’s also the first time they’ll ever receive a letter grade.
That transition can be challenging because of the uncertainty that comes with switching grading systems, especially when students are unsure of the purpose of the middle school system. The middle school grading system, or “standards-based grading,” as the school calls it, is meant to provide a more holistic overview of a student’s progress in middle school. Yet many students and faculty have a different understanding of what “standards-based grading” really entails.
For any given middle-school assessment, instead of receiving a single grade for the assignment as a whole, students are graded on multiple different standards. In English class, for example, a student might receive separate grades on their analysis, sentence fluency and grammar.
As opposed to the high school’s classic A–F system, the middle school gives students one of four scores: exceeding, demonstrating, progressing or limited progression. “Exceeding” indicates that the student’s performance is above the teacher’s expectations for the class; “demonstrating” means they’re meeting those expectations; “progressing” means they need to do more work to reach the expectations; and “limited progression” means the student is not at class level for the evaluated standard.
According to Middle School Principal Kelsey Schroeder, there’s more to the middle school grading system than replacing letter grades with words. “The function of a report card is to communicate to both the student and the parent feedback on what they have learned and where they still have room to grow,” Schroeder said. “So the goal is to say, ‘Have you met the expectation for my class yet, or have you not gotten there quite yet?’”
Each trimester, students are also assessed on classroom behavior and time management—things like coming to class on time and responding to teacher feedback—which the middle school calls transferable skills.
Julia Blount ’08, eighth-grade dean and history teacher, said that even before the middle school implemented the current system, some teachers were already grading students on multiple skills for each assignment and averaging the separate grades into a final letter grade.
Then, in 2018, the school officially began using its current grading system after Joe Feldman—author of Grading for Equity: What It Is, Why It Matters, and How It Can Transform Schools and Classrooms—led a series of workshops for faculty about the importance of grading students separately on classroom behavior.
“Standards-based grading allows for more specificity, more equity, and it removes the opportunity for me to use my personal biases that we all have,” Blount said.
Blount gave an example of what she meant by personal biases: If a student speaks more in class, a teacher may assume that student knows the material better than a student who doesn’t speak and give the more talkative student a better grade. But because in the middle school, transferable skills are assessed separately from the actual assignment, Blount would be able to assess that student separately on participation and the content of their work.
However, ninth-grade history teacher Anthony Belber said student engagement isn’t always shown verbally. “I’d say that there are many ways for students to show their engagement,” Belber said. He said students who are less inclined to speak in class can show their engagement through the way they journal or respond to homework questions.
Skylar Rampersaud, a parent of a GDS seventh- and tenth-grader, said the system helps parents better understand their children’s academic progress. “It’s more informative to get a report card that says ‘Progressing in grammar and spelling’ than just a B in English,” she said. “You’re getting more information about the students’ skill level.”
Some students, though, had a rude awakening when they came to the high school.
“I really liked [middle school] because it was less pressure, but I feel like it didn’t really prepare me for high school,” freshman Josie Biel said. “I’ve already had so many quizzes this week, and I got some back, and I was like, ‘I have no idea what’s happening.’”
Freshman Ella Mckenzie said the middle school teachers did not always give students a clear understanding of how their grades would translate into letter grades. “All we hear is, ‘Oh, you’re gonna have to get a letter grade.’ It was such a big leap, but I didn’t really get a lot of information,” McKenzie said.
Some students said they thought the middle school’s grading system was ambiguous and were sometimes unsure of how teachers determined their grade.
Seventh- and eighth-grade history teacher Erika Carlson said, in the history department, if a teacher is unsure of what grade a student’s work deserves, they will meet with another history teacher and decide on the student’s grade. Carlson said collaboration between history teachers helps ensure teachers are grading students’ work consistently.
Carlson also said history teachers in each grade meet weekly to discuss the upcoming week and rubrics for upcoming assignments.
According to Schroeder, the middle school grading system may also help students recognize skills they need to improve on across classes.
“History and English and science—they’re all different subjects, but sometimes there are similar skills that’ll come up in each class,” Carlson said, citing source analysis as an example.
In her eighth-grade Chinese class, McKenzie received both a middle school grade and a corresponding letter grade on one assignment. She said that having both of those grades helped her better understand the comparison between the two systems. But she wished all of her teachers had given her letter grades at least once before she transitioned to high school.
“I feel like the range of grading was really big between what constituted a demonstrating versus a progressing,” senior Ava Comly said.
Ninth-grade science teacher Elaina Berres said because there are 13 possible grades high-schoolers can receive—as opposed to the middle school’s four—students may find it difficult to understand how their middle school grades correlate to their high school grades.
“I think they should show us what the grading system really is before going into high school,” junior Lucky Dodge said. “Maybe give us an [A–F graded] quiz or something before high school.”
“I feel like if there was some sort of transition [in the grading styles] that would be helpful, especially for eighth-graders to know what’s coming,” sophomore Nora Son said.
Although Rampersaud was largely in favor of the middle school grading system, she said introducing letter grades in eighth-grade would improve the transition.
Blount said the middle school has tried to prepare students for the transition by giving them opportunities to receive letter grades; she said that last year, eighth-grade teachers were required to grade one assignment on the A–F scale. However, Blount said converting middle school grades into their high school equivalent is difficult because expectations are different for middle school and high school students.
“I can’t say to an eighth-grader, ‘This is what your grade will be in ninth-grade on an A–F scale’ because it’s not necessarily going to be the same, depending on who the [high school] teacher is,” Blount said. “There’s some limitations to our ability to give a direct correlation. I do think the most important thing is preparing students for the types of questions and assignments that they’re going to get at the high school, as opposed to focusing on the numerical value,” Blount said.
“The most important thing to me is that you have the skills and knowledge to be successful in [high school] courses,” Schroeder said. “My philosophy is that when you have really well-educated students, the grades often take care of themselves.”
But Schroeder acknowledged that the transition between the middle school and high school can be difficult. She said that in recent years, eighth-grade teachers have worked with ninth-grade teachers to better align the expectations and curriculum between the two grades. Schroeder specifically highlighted the similarities between eighth- and ninth-grade history classes. “There was a really wonderful effort between the eighth-grade history team and the ninth-grade history team to look at the parallels between the way we’re teaching the [eighth-grade] Constitutional Issue Paper and the FReP [Freshman Research Paper].”
Belber said the ninth-grade history teachers meet with middle school history teachers a few times a year to discuss the curricula for both grades. “I always feel like the middle schoolers are well prepared for the FReP,” Belber said.